- 25.1.12.1 Overview
- 25.1.12.2 General Procedures for Referral of Violations
- 25.1.12.3 Development of Willfulness
- 25.1.12.4 Referral Recommendations - Criminal Referral is Not Recommended
- 25.1.12.5 Referral Recommendations - Criminal Referral is Recommended
- 25.1.12.6 Preparation and Processing of Form 2797
- 25.1.12.7 Joint Title 26 - Title 31 Criminal Referral Disclosure Concern
- 25.1.12.8 Parallel Civil and Criminal Leads
- 25.1.12.9 BSA Leads
- Exhibit 25.1.12-1 IRS Standards for Title 31 Referrals to FinCEN
-
The purpose of this section of the Fraud Handbook is to notify field compliance employees of a policy and procedural change affecting the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and the National Fraud Program (NFP). This guidance is required to improve the quality of civil and criminal referrals of BSA violations. The procedures apply to BSA Title 31 cases, Form 8300 (Report of Cash Payments Over $10,000 Received in a Trade or Business) cases worked under Title 31 and Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts Report (FBAR) violations.
-
BSA civil enforcement cases are referred to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) via Form 5104, Report of Apparent Violation of Financial Recordkeeping and Reporting Regulations, for consideration of appropriate enforcement action. Form 8300 and FBAR civil penalties are assessed by IRS, so they are not referred to FinCEN.
-
Civil penalty referrals are no longer forwarded to Criminal Investigation (CI) for review.
-
Form 2797, Referral Report of Potential Fraud Cases , is used to refer BSA Title 31 case, Form 8300 and FBAR criminal violations to CI for criminal investigation consideration.
-
Revenue Agent Fraud Technical Advisors (FTAs) will assist in the development of indicators of willfulness or intent, the determination of affirmative acts of willfulness or intent, and the preparation of Form 2797 (if needed). Also, the FTAs may assist BSA in the preparation of Form 5104, Report of Apparent Violation of Financial Recordkeeping and Reporting Regulations , a civil enforcement referral to FinCEN.
-
If indications and/or affirmative acts of intentional or willful BSA Title 31 case, Form 8300, or FBAR violations are discovered, the examiner will discuss the potential violations with the group manager. The examiner, with the approval of the group manager, will contact the local FTA for guidance. If the examiner is considering only a civil referral to FinCEN, the involvement of the FTA is at the discretion of the examiner and group manager.
-
If the decision to involve the FTA is made, the examiner will initiate completion of Form 13639, Fraudulent Intent Referral Memorandum (FIRM). Form 13639 documents the involvement of the FTA, the plan for developing the case with respect to the willfulness issue, and the referral recommendations of the FTA.
-
The examiner documents indications and/or affirmative acts of willfulness in Part 3 of Form 13639. The FTA documents the referral recommendations by checking one of the boxes in Part 6 of Form 13639 and lists the reason(s) for certain recommendations in the Explanation section of Form 13639.
-
Civil enforcement on Form 5104 referrals will be forwarded through Microsoft Outlook/Secured Messaging to the SB/SE FinCEN. See Exhibit 25.1.12-1, IRS Standards for Title 31 Referrals to FinCEN liaison, for guidance regarding when a referral is appropriate. The SB/SE FinCEN liaison will arrange for the CI FinCEN liaison to review the referral prior to forwarding it to FinCEN for civil enforcement consideration.
-
If further examination is warranted to determine if a violation was willful:
-
The FTA will prepare a plan of action for further examination to determine whether a violation was willful in the Explanation section of Form 13639 and return a copy of Form 13639 to the examiner through the group manager.
-
The examiner and the FTA will work together to carry out the examination plan.
-
If affirmative acts (firm indications) of willfulness are discovered after further examination, the examiner will immediately contact the FTA for guidance. Under no circumstances should the examiner contact CI.
-
-
Upon completing the plan of action for further examination to determine whether a violation was willful; the examiner, group manager, and FTA will discuss the results and reach a conclusion regarding a criminal referral. The FTA will memorialize this conclusion on the initial Form 13639 or a second (follow-up) Form 13639 will be completed and stapled to the initial Form 13639. The FTA will indicate in Part 6 of Form 13639 (original or follow-up) the final referral recommendation; either firm indications of willfulness and criminal criteria are present and preparation of Form 2797 is recommended, or criminal investigation is not appropriate. The FTA will provide, in the Explanationsection, the reason(s) why a criminal referral is not appropriate or, if a criminal referral is recommended, a detail of the firm indications of willfulness.
-
If further examination is not warranted in determining if a violation was willful, the FTA will indicate so in Part 6 of Form 13639 and provide a written explanation of the reason(s) why further examination to determine if a violation was willful is not warranted and include any recommendations with respect to civil penalties in the Explanation section of the form. The examiner may proceed with the routine case procedures.
-
BSA Title 31 Case Procedures:
-
The examiner will secure delinquent BSA forms (IRM 4.26.8.4, Delinquent BSA Forms) and issue Letter 1112, Title 31 Violation Notification Letter, if the violations do not meet the criteria for referral to FinCEN (see IRM 4.26.8.5, Letter 1112).
-
If the violations meet the criteria for a referral to FinCEN, the examiner will prepare and process Form 5104 (see IRM 4.26.8, Form 5104, Report of Apparent Violation of Financial Recordkeeping and Reporting Regulations ).
-
-
FBAR Procedures:
-
The examiner should secure delinquent or amended FBAR forms (see IRM 4.26.17.4.8, Delinquent FBAR Processing) and consider issuing Letter 3800, Warning Letter Respecting Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts Report Apparent Violations(see IRM 4.26.17.4.2, Closing the FBAR Case - Warning Letter).
-
If civil penalties are being considered, see IRM 4.26.4, FBAR Penalties, and IRM 4.26.17.4.3, Closing the FBAR Case with Penalties, through IRM 4.26.17.4.7, Closing the FBAR Case Appealed.
-
-
Form 8300 Procedures:
-
With group manager concurrence, the examiner should secure delinquent Forms 8300 (see IRM 4.26.11.4.5.1, Delinquent Form 8300 Procedures ).
-
Unlike BSA and FBAR examinations, a warning letter is not issued in Form 8300 cases.
-
If civil penalties are being considered, see IRM 20.1.7, Information return Penalties , IRM 4.26.11.4.6, Civil Penalties, IRM 4.26.4.6, Penalties Asserted on IRC Section 6050I Violations, and IRM 4.26.11.5.4, Penalty Case File.
-
-
If firm indications of willful BSA, FBAR, or Form 8300 violations exist and criminal criteria (criteria used by CI for case acceptance) are met:
-
The FTA will:
i. Recommend preparation of Form 2797 in Part 6 of Form 13639;
ii. Indicate in the Explanation section of Form 13639, the firm indications of willfulness that exist and that criminal criteria are met; and
iii. Return a copy of Form 13639 to the examiner through the group manager.
-
The examiner will suspend all civil examination activity and retain the civil file for subsequent action.
-
The group manager will record the suspense on the BSA database by entering the date Form 2797 was referred to CI.
-
The sole responsibility for protecting the statute rests with the examiner and group manager; BSA Workload, Identification, Selection, Delivery and Monitoring (WISDM) does not monitor the statute of limitations. A meeting will be held between the examiner, group manager and CI to determine whether or not the statute of limitations should be allowed to expire.
-
-
See IRM 4.26.17.5.4 for additional procedures dealing with FBAR cases.
-
The following procedures apply to cases worked under Title 31 only. Most Form 8300 examinations are conducted under Title 26. The preparation and processing of Form 2797 for Title 26 examinations is prescribed in IRM 25.1.3.
-
The examiner is required to use the current version of Form 2797 located on the Forms Repository. The web address of the Forms Repository is http://publish.no.irs.gov/catlg.html .
-
When preparing Form 2797 for a BSA violation, the examiner will follow the instructions attached to the form (Page 4) and:
-
Note that filer means the person required to file a report regardless of whether or not the person filed.
-
Insert the type of violation (FBAR, Form 8300, Currency Transaction Report (CTR)) and/or Suspicious Activity Report (SAR), etc.) in item 2f.
-
Note in item 3d that Web Currency Banking and Retrieval System (Web-CBRS) must be checked for a BSA violation referral. The following are instructions for the specific items, included in a Title 31 criminal referral (Form 2797):
-
Name and Address of Filer, TIN, and Personal Data - Information must come from a Title 31 source (compliance examination, Web-CBRS, etc.). Internal IRS data sources, such as Information Data Retrieval System (IDRS), cannot be used to ascertain this information, unless a related statute determination was made.
-
Basis for the Suspected Fraud - Item f should be checked and identified as a Title 31 issue (for example, structuring, FBAR/CTR reporting violation). Items a through d, and usually e, do not pertain to Title 31.
-
Description of Affirmative Acts - Description should not indicate anything that is Title 26-related, including assumptions.
-
Describe Summonses Served (if any) - Title 26 summonses should not be mentioned, unless a related statute determination was made.
-
List all Investigative Sources Checked (IDRS, Web-CBRS, Credit Bureau, Choicepoint, Public Records, etc.) - IDRS should not be accessed or mentioned, and information from the other sources listed (Web-CBRS, Credit Bureau, etc.) should not be used if that information is taken from a Title 26 case file, unless a related statute determination was made.
-
Defense Given by Filer or Representative - Explanation provided with respect to the Title 31 examination only.
-
Comment on prior/subsequent year returns, if this is a single year referral - Comment should be limited to Title 31 Reports.
-
Description of Records - Limit description to records, which identify Title 31 transactions (for example, cash receipts/cash disbursements journal, cashed checks), unless a related statute determination was made.
-
Describe Basis or Method Used for the Computation of the Fraud Adjustments - Description should be limited to the Title 31 penalty adjustments.
-
Non-Taxable Sources of Income and Cash on Hand - Include only if relevant to the Title 31 penalty adjustments. Do not include any information taken from a Title 26 case file, unless a related statute determination was made.
-
Administrative Information - Omit.
-
-
-
See IRM 25.1.3 for detailed instructions concerning the processing of Form 2797.
-
The procedures prescribed below do not apply to Form 8300 examinations conducted under Title 26.
-
A memorandum of understanding (MOU) between SB/SE BSA and FinCEN provides for the following:
"Matters Referred to IRS CI – If a matter involving a BSA violation is to be referred to CI, the IRS will provide FinCEN with a copy of the portion of the referral package to CI that is related to BSA violations or deficiencies at the same time the IRS provides the referral package to CI. Until CI either rejects the referral or clears the BSA matter for civil enforcement consideration, FinCEN agrees not to share the referral package and the information contained therein with a third party or to otherwise take any action with respect to such information without first obtaining written approval from CI."
In order to meet this requirement, the NFP BSA Liaison will forward a copy of the Forms 2797, via Microsoft Outlook/Secured Messaging to the BSA senior program analyst that has the IRS/FinCEN MOU responsibility for reviewing the Forms 2797 for potential disclosure violations. The BSA program analyst will ensure that the Forms 2797 do not contain any "tax return information " prior to forwarding them to FinCEN.
-
If return information is included in the referral, access to and use of IRC § 6103 protected information, such as IDRS data, for non-tax purposes is not permitted. Its use may constitute a violation of IRC § 7213 and/or § 7213A (unauthorized disclosure and/or unauthorized access). See IRM 4.26.14 for further information on disclosure and BSA, unless a related statute determination has been made. Information obtained from Title 26 examinations cannot be included in Title 31 criminal referrals (Forms 2797), if a related statute determination has not been made. A disclosure violation may also occur even when a related statute determination has been made, if the person to whom the disclosure is made does not have a "need to know," with respect to the tax information included in the referral. Thus, Title 31 criminal referrals will not include Title 26 return information, except as mentioned in the instructions under IRM 25.1.12.6(2), and if a related statute determination is made, a copy of the related statute determination memorandum must be attached to Form 2797.
-
Prior to the disposition conference, it may be helpful for the group manager to contact the SB/SE and/or the CI FinCEN liaison for assistance in determining whether parallel civil and criminal action may be appropriate.
-
During the disposition conference, if the case is being accepted for criminal investigation, the participants should discuss the possibility of parallel civil and criminal actions. A civil money penalty may be imposed, notwithstanding the fact that a criminal penalty is imposed with respect to the same violation. Parallel referrals may be desirable in order to protect the statute of limitations or for other reasons.
-
If a case is determined to warrant parallel civil and criminal actions, it should be noted in the Form 5104 referral.
-
Before the civil referral is considered by FinCEN, the CI FinCEN liaison will review the referral for compatibility with CI needs. FinCEN will not receive the referral for civil enforcement action until this review is completed.
-
Evidence of violations that do not meet the criminal/local criteria requirements may be referred by the examiner as an information item. Information items are documented by the examiner on Form 13639 and forwarded to the BSA coordinator at:
Internal Revenue Service
290 Broadway, 5th Floor
Attention: BSA Coordinator
New York, NY 10007
-
The BSA coordinator will determine if the information referral should be routed to the local CI Suspicious Activity Report-Review Team (SAR-RT) coordinator for consideration as a referral of information to another agency, which may have jurisdiction over related crimes, or to the appropriate CI field office for further development. Any developed leads will be assigned a source code reflecting SB/SE BSA as the source of the information.
-
Evidence of customers engaging in substantial check cashing, money order purchase/redemption, wire transmission, etc. should be captured on Form 5346, Examination Information Report. It is crucial that copies of all supporting evidence (cashed checks [front and back], money orders, wire transmission receipts, etc.) are included. The examiner will prepare the Forms 5346, retain a copy of each form for the case file, and forward the completed Forms 5346 to the group manager for approval. Upon approval, the group manager will forward the forms for Title 31 and/or Title 26 violation consideration to the BSA coordinator at the address identified above.
To provide consistency on when a referral should be made to FinCEN, the following guidelines are provided to assist you in taking the appropriate action.
For purposes of referring matters to FinCEN a "significant BSA violation or deficiency" includes: a systemic or pervasive BSA compliance program deficiency; systemic or pervasive BSA reporting or recordkeeping violations; a situation where an organization fails to respond to regulatory actions concerning BSA compliance program deficiencies; or, systemic or pervasive recordkeeping or reporting deficiencies, even when such deficiencies or violations are dissimilar to those previously identified in Letters 1112 or other IRS/FinCEN correspondence. A significant BSA violation or deficiency also includes a non-technical, one-time BSA violation which demonstrates willful or reckless disregard for the requirements of the BSA, or that creates a substantial risk of money laundering or the financing of terrorism within the institution.
As stated earlier, technical, minor, infrequent, isolated, and non-substantive violations will generally not be referred to FinCEN.
First-time violations may be appropriate for referral depending upon their nature, severity, number, and circumstance. Normally, isolated first incidences of noncompliance should not be referred. If an entity is cited subsequently for the same types of violations, the examiner should closely scrutinize the continued lack of compliance in determining whether a referral is appropriate.
Any violation committed in furtherance of a criminal activity warrants referral regardless of the number, severity, or that it was a first violation.
If during a BSA examination, it is discovered that a bank or other financial institution, not covered under IRS BSA examination authority, may have violated the BSA, a memorandum to FinCEN should be prepared outlining the circumstances. The memorandum must be routed through the Territory Manager and forwarded to the IRS FinCEN liaison for forwarding to FinCEN’s Office of Compliance.
General Civil Penalty Referral Guidelines
Many of the BSA civil penalties require that the violation be "willful". Willfulness requires an intentional violation of a known legal duty. In many situations, there will be no direct evidence to establish willfulness; therefore, examiners will often need to establish willfulness through circumstantial evidence. An examiner should consider the following factors in determining whether willfulness exists and whether violations should be formally referred to FinCEN:
-
Pattern of reckless disregard towards, or systemic breakdown in, compliance with the anti-money laundering program requirements of the BSA;
-
Evidence that the violation has, or may have, facilitated or concealed illegal activity by the institution, its employees, its customers, or others;
-
Evidence that suggests the violation was flagrant, demonstrated bad faith, or was committed with disregard for the law or the consequences to the institution;
-
Frequency or reoccurrence of violations;
-
Continuation of violations after the institution became aware of them and/or made no efforts to correct the deficiencies, which led to the violations;
-
Failure to cooperate with the Service to correct the violation;
-
Evidence of concealment of the violation;
-
Evidence that financial institution insiders were participants in the currency transaction, or that their associates directly or indirectly benefited as a result of the violation;
-
History of prior violations and/or poor compliance;
-
Previous written criticism of the institution for similar violations;
-
Absence of/severe inadequacies in/or failure to adhere to the requirements of internal control policies and procedures or compliance program;
-
Issuance of a previous warning letter or other previous written notification of a violation to the financial institution;
-
The practice of preparing but not filing CTRs or SARs;
-
Repeated late filings of CTRs or SARs;
-
Filing CTRs with incomplete or false information;
-
Filing SARs with incomplete or false information;
-
Failures to verify identification;
-
Failure to keep records;
-
False recordkeeping entries; and/or
-
Officers and employees of the financial institution making false statements, refusing to cooperate, and/or withholding records from the examiner.
The above listing is not all inclusive
Examples of situations which might also warrant a referral:
-
Failure to file FinCEN Form 104,Currency Transaction Report , Form TD F 90-22.56, Suspicious Activity Report by Money Services Businesses (SAR-MSB), FinCEN Form 102, Suspicious Activity Report by Casinos and Card Clubs (SAR-C), or Form 103, Currency Transaction Report by Casinos (CTR-C),
-
A significant number of reportable transactions that were not reported as a pattern or practice at a certain location or as a pattern or practice for one or more specific customers or accounts,
-
A significant number of technical violations i.e., incomplete or inaccurate FinCEN Form 104 or Form 8362. For example, referral may be warranted if samples of CTRs filed reveal error rates that exceed a certain percentage or a systemic breakdown,
-
Failure to maintain a centralized exempt customer list by a credit union/bank under IRS jurisdiction that exempts certain customer accounts from Title 31 reporting requirements,
-
Inclusion of ineligible entities on the exemption list by credit union/bank under IRS jurisdiction in situations that would otherwise require that filings be made,
-
Lack of adequate internal controls or audit coverage or inaccuracies in the financial institution’s training materials regarding Title 31, in combination with violations of Title 31 reporting and recordkeeping requirements, and
-
Continued violation of the financial recordkeeping and reporting regulations of Title 31 despite notification of violations.
Systemic or Pervasive Violations Customarily Warranting Civil Referral
-
Pattern of reckless disregard towards, or systemic breakdown in, compliance with the anti-money laundering program requirements of the Bank Secrecy Act,
-
Repeated failures to file required CTRs or Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs),
-
Repeated failures to verify the identification of the transactor,
-
Repeated filing of incomplete CTRs lacking key information,
-
Flagrant indifference by the financial institution or aiding the customer in structuring transactions to avoid the reporting requirements, and or
-
Suspected money laundering activity.