- 34.5.3 Suits Brought Against the United States
- 22.214.171.124 Civil Actions Brought Against the U.S. By Persons Other Than Taxpayers
- 126.96.36.199 Wrongful Levy Section7426(a)(1)
- 188.8.131.52 Surplus Proceeds Section7426(a)(2)
- 184.108.40.206 Substituted Sales Proceeds Section7426(a)(3)
- 220.127.116.11 Substitution of Value Suits Section7426(a)(4)
- 18.104.22.168 Miscellaneous Procedural Matters
Part 34. Litigation in District Court, Bankruptcy Court, Court of Federal Claims, and State Court
Chapter 5. Suits Brought Against the United States
Section 3. Suits Brought Against the United States
This section covers the types of civil actions that may be brought against the United States by persons other than taxpayers under section 7426.
Section 7426(a)(1) authorizes a suit directly against the United States by a third person claiming that the Government wrongfully levied upon such person’s property to satisfy the tax liability of another. Wrongful, as used in this section, refers to a proceeding against property that is not the taxpayer’s. In general, if a levy has been made on property, or property has been sold pursuant to a levy, any person other than the taxpayer who claims an interest in or lien on such property, may bring a civil action against the United States.
An action under section 7426 may be brought without regard to whether the property has been surrendered to or sold by the Government. It may not be brought prior to the time the Government has in fact levied upon the property.
The remedies provided by section 7426 are the exclusive means of redress for actions that may be brought under this section.
The injunctive relief afforded by section 7426(b)(1) is available:
Only in wrongful levy actions brought under section 7426(a)(1);
Only after the property has in fact been levied upon by the United States;
Only if the court determines that the levy has been wrongful
If the levy or a sale of property pursuant to the levy would irreparably injure the rights of a third party in such property; and
If the rights of such third party in such property are superior to the rights of the United States.
If the court’s determination is in favor of the third party, typically the injunction is either made permanent, where the Government does not have possession of the property, or is continued until the levy is released and the specific property is returned to the person.
If the court determines the Government’s levy is wrongful, the court may under section 7426(b)(2):
Order the return of specific property if the property is identifiable and the United States is in possession of such property.
Grant a judgment for the amount of money levied upon.
Grant a judgment for an amount not exceeding the amount received by the United States from the sale of such property, or the fair market value of such property immediately before the levy.
Where a third party recovers a money judgment, interest at the rate set by section 6621 is allowed from the date the Government received the money wrongfully levied upon to the date of payment of such judgment. Money wrongfully levied upon is "received" at the time the Government acquired possession of such money.
Section 7426(h) authorizes the payment of actual, economic damages incurred by a third party in a wrongful levy suit if there is a finding that an officer or employee recklessly, intentionally, or negligently disregarded a provision of the Code. The third party must exhaust administrative remedies under the same rules set forth in section 7433(d).
Section 7426(a)(2) provides that if surplus proceeds have been realized from the sale of property by the United States pursuant to a levy, any person (other than the taxpayer) who claims an interest in or lien upon such property junior to the lien or interest of the United States, and claims to be legally entitled to all or part of such surplus proceeds, may bring an action against the United States in a district court of the United States.
"Surplus proceeds" are those in excess of the amount necessary to satisfy the tax liability giving rise to the levy and the expenses of the levy sale. Once a taxpayer’s liability is satisfied, the Government’s retention of surplus proceeds is wrongful as to the person legally entitled to them.
Section 7426(b)(3) provides that if the court determines that the interest or lien of any party to an action under section 7426 was transferred to the proceeds of sale or property sold pursuant to a levy, the court may grant a judgment against the United States in an amount equal to all or any part of the amount of the surplus proceeds of such sale. The relief available under this section may be granted only in cases brought under section 7426(a)(2).
Section 7426(a)(3) was enacted to provide that if property has been sold pursuant to an agreement described in section 6325(b)(3), any person (including the taxpayer) who claims to be legally entitled to all or any part of the amount held as a fund pursuant to such agreement, may join the Government in a civil action to assert a claim to those proceeds.
Section 6325(b) permits the issuance of a certificate of discharge where property subject to a tax lien is sold and, under an agreement with the Service, the proceeds from the sale are held as a fund subject to the liens and claims of the United States in the same manner, and with the same priority, as the liens and claims on the discharged property. This provision was instituted to aid in the disposition of property where a dispute exists among competing lienors, including the United States, concerning their rights to specific property.
Any person including the taxpayer may bring an action under this provision whether or not such person was a party to the agreement described in section 6325(b)(3).
Section 7426(b)(4) provides that if the court determines that a party has an interest in or a lien upon an amount held as a fund pursuant to an agreement providing for the proceeds of sale of property to be substituted for the property, the court may grant a judgment in an amount not in excess of the substituted sale proceeds.
If a certificate of discharge is issued to any person under section 6325(b)(4) with respect to any property, such person may, within 120 days after the day on which such certificate is issued, bring a civil action against the United States for a determination of whether the value of the interest of the United States (if any) in such property is less than the value determined by the Service. No other action may be brought by such person for such a determination.
The following covers the miscellaneous procedural matters related to civil actions brought against the United States by persons other than taxpayers.
Section 7426(c) provides that, for purposes of an adjudication under section 7426, the assessment of tax upon which the interest or lien of the United States is based shall be conclusively presumed to be valid. Thus, the merits of the tax liability are not contestable unless the United States asks affirmatively for foreclosure of its lien in such actions.
Section 6532(c) provides a period of limitation on suits by persons other than taxpayers. Generally, except as provided in section 6532(c)(2), no suit or proceeding under section 7426 shall begin after nine months from the date of the levy or agreement giving rise to such action.
Section 7426(d) provides for a limitation on rights of action in that no action may be maintained against any officer or employee of the United States (or former officer or employee) or his/her personal representative with respect to any action that could be maintained under section 7426. If an action that could be brought against the United States under this section is improperly brought against one of the aforementioned individuals, the pleadings may be amended to substitute the United States as a party-defendant for such individual, as of the time such action was commenced, upon proper service of process on the United States. See section 7426(e).
Section 7426(f) provides that the provisions of section 7422(a) (relating to prohibition of suit prior to filing claim for refund) shall not apply to actions under section 7426. It is, therefore, unnecessary for a person to file an administrative claim for a refund before instituting an action under section 7426.
An administrative claim may be filed seeking the recovery of property wrongfully levied upon, under section 6343(b) (relating to return of property), although the filing of such claim is not a prerequisite to the commencement of an action under section 7426(a)(1).
Similarly, the filing of an administrative application under section 6342(b) (relating to surplus proceeds), seeking a distribution of surplus proceeds resulting from a sale of property pursuant to levy, is not a prerequisite to the commencement of an action under section 7426(a)(2).
On occasion the taxpayer will initiate a proceeding in the federal district court to perpetuate the testimony of some witness believed to be relevant and material to a potential tax case. The appropriate Civil Trial Section of the Tax Division handles these cases, and they are handled as suits brought against the United States and opened as collection cases in the Office of Chief Counsel.
Upon receipt of information that such a case has been commenced, Counsel should assemble all facts and files and then prepare a letter addressed to the Tax Division, Attn: Civil Trial Section, ____________Region. Such letter should be in the form of a defense letter and contain a recommendation as to whether the petition should be opposed. The letter will be signed on behalf of Chief Counsel in the field office and forwarded to the Tax Division.
All facts and files will be made available to the DJ lawyer handling the case.
Since the results of the case and any related papers could be pertinent to any future Tax Court case or refund suit, special efforts should be made to associate the immediate information with any Service files for future use.
The above procedures apply only where there is no suit already commenced by the taxpayer.